By signing up you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, Interpretation of the news based on evidence, including data, as well as anticipating how events might unfold based on past events. All told, our most recent records show that 139 monuments have been officially removed since 1880. Business Insider/Madison Hoff, data from Southern Poverty Law Center. Nathan T. Carrington is a PhD candidate in political science at Syracuse University and a research associate at the Campbell Public Affairs Institute. Here’s the data. Protesters have recently torn down or painted over monuments of Confederate leaders and other colonialist figures. According to a recent Time article, the Virginia Senate Republican Caucus issued a statement saying the removal of Robert E. Lee statue is "not in the best interests of Virginia.". Northam recently talked about the plan to remove the Robert E. Lee statue in Richmond, Virginia, and Richmond Mayor Levar Stoney said a new ordinance is planned for July 1 that will require all Confederate monuments in the city to be removed, according to WHSV. D.C. Council hears testimony on changing police practices to bring more acc... A young man’s path out of Houston’s oldest housing project echoes George Fl... Protester files claim against D.C. National Guard, saying she was injured b... At Jack Yates High School, sports — not study — was seen as the ticket out. Black people have protested police killings for years. “In many cases, these monuments have been here for so long. There are 1,747 Confederate monuments or symbols that still stand around the US, according to the SPLC. A leading-edge research firm focused on digital transformation. Because the government had the final say on what monuments were allowed, the Supreme Court said these monuments were a form of government speech as they were an expression of the government’s favored viewpoints. The US Marine Corps similarly banned the Confederate flag. More than 30 cities either have removed or are removing Confederate monuments, according to a list compiled by The New York Times, and the … Although media coverage often focuses on … We didn’t specify whose speech might be violated. Understanding this is important because of the heavy emphasis on rights in the United States. Part of the commemoration of the American Civil War, these symbols include monuments and statues, flags, holidays and other observances, and the names of schools, roads, parks, bridges, counties, cities, lakes, dams, military bases, and other public works. Additionally, what happened to the Confederate statues in Baltimore? We decided to take a look at how many of those monuments still stand across the country. This is true whether the city commissioned the monument or a private individual donated it. Buyenlarge/Getty Images, FILE A Confederate monument stands in … There are nearly 800 Confederate monuments and statues on public property throughout the country, the vast majority in the South. 123 4 5. Protesters have also pulled down statues themselves in Virginia, as reported by The Washington Post. The Confederate statues were put up when they were put up [not just after the war but largely during periods of Civil Rights tension in the 20th century], to send a message about white supremacy, and to sentimentalize people who had actively fought to preserve the system of slavery. There are 1,747 Confederate monuments or symbols that still stand around the US, according to the SPLC. At least thirty-two Confederate monuments were dedicated between 2000 and 2017, including at least 7 re-dedications. As of June 9, there were nearly 1,800 Confederate monuments, statues, and other symbols in the US. Find him on Twitter @NateCarrington. In our survey sample, this wasn’t a widely held idea. The Southern Poverty Law Center shared with Business Insider two recent instances in Alabama of the removal of Confederate symbols. The statue of Confederate General Robert E. Lee in the center of Emancipation Park the day after the Unite the Right rally led to violence on August 13, 2017 in Charlottesville, Virginia. Here’s what seemed to drive the viewpoint about removing Southern icons violating free speech: unfavorable views of African Americans relative to whites; and, to a lesser extent, self-reported “Southern pride.”. It is difficult to argue that removing Confederate monuments from public spaces infringes on the right to free speech found in the Constitution. Now, in the wake of the current protests, many officials are discussing removing monuments and other symbols that they say demonstrate racism in the US. A part of the Veterans Garden of Honor (1998) which features nine life sized statues of soldiers from various wars, the statue in question depicts a union soldier and a confederate soldier back to back with a young slave at their feet holding a plaque reading "Freedom to Slaves," and the date January 5, 1863. As of June 29, 2020 , there is at least one known public monument of a confederate soldier in Michigan. Rockville’s Thin Gray Line Then, it was re-labeled as the Lost Cause, whatever that means, by Confederate diehards in the late-1900s. In fact, there are two such monuments … Twenty eight were dedicated between 1950 and 1970. So the question is why are there so many public statues of Confederate generals and political leaders scattered in the South? A few days later, he vowed to fight a temporary injunction to its removal. For example, if the government wants to run an antismoking campaign, it need not also run a pro-smoking campaign. Racial disparities in D.C. police stops at center of dialogue during 10-day... For George Floyd and Black men in recovery, ‘everything just piles up’. Our survey found that relatively few people are likely to claim that Confederate statues are a form of free speech. since, “No Rules Rules: Netflix and the Culture of Reinvention”. New Orleans mayor on why Confederate monuments have … To date, there are over 700 monuments to the Confederacy - most, but not all, located in the South. There now are 13 statues of Confederate figures scattered around the Capitol, including Davis, Lee, and Florida’s Edmund Kirby Smith, one of the last Confederate generals to surrender. Logan Strother is an assistant professor of political science at Purdue University. “Rights framing” — talking about political or social issues in expressly rights-based terms — can help mobilize supporters of keeping statues where they are, including those who might otherwise remain on the sideline. Importantly, if the government is “speaking,” it’s free to endorse any viewpoint it wishes. The statue was removed on August 16, 2017, on the order of Baltimore City Council, but the base still remains. Just over 14 percent of those surveyed said that removing Confederate statues is a free speech violation. Mayors and state governors, colleges, and other organizations have already taken down or are considering removing Confederate monuments, banning Confederate flags, and renaming places currently named after Confederate leaders. On June 4, Gov. Eleven statues in the National Statuary Hall Collection commemorate Confederate soldiers and officials, including several in their Confederate uniforms. How many Confederate statues are there? Find him on Twitter @LoganRStrother. In sum, our survey found that only a minority of Americans see removing Confederate icons from public spaces as a violation of the principle of free speech. More importantly, those statues honor people who fought for a nation founded … A Confederate monument in Portsmouth, Virginia, that was partially brought down by protesters injured someone, according to local Harrisonburg, Virginia, news station WHSV. The great waves of Confederate monument building took place in the 1890s, as the Confederacy was coming to be idealized as the so-called Lost … A look into the tech transformations underway at the world's largest companies. There are at least 12 Confederate statues in the National Statuary Hall Collection of the Capitol building. 4 days ago. Maybe it is because the rebellion of the Confederacy against the Union was painted as a states’ rights campaign. Those hoping to keep the symbols in place often argue that they care about preserving history — but another common argument declares a constitutional breach: that removing Confederate memorials from public spaces is a violation of free speech. Here’s why officials are finally responding. The majority (604) were dedicated before 1950. A new law in Virginia will allow local governments to decide what to do with monuments. The most important news stories of the day, curated by Post editors and delivered every morning. The remainder are other symbols like parks, military bases, highway names, and government buildings named after Confederate officials. The University of Alabama on June 9 decided to remove a Confederate memorial plaque after a swift vote by the board of trustees on June 8, according to Tuscaloosanews.com. Albert Pike was torn down, but there are still many monuments at the U.S. Capitol. Some officials have voiced opposition to removing the monuments. However, Confederate monuments — possibly up to 1,000 total, according to USA Today — can be found in 31 states as well as in the District of Columbia. Get it now on Libro.fm using the button below. Protesters are demanding they be taken down. As of June 9, there were nearly 1,800 Confederate monuments, statues, and other symbols in the US. But other research has shown how attitudes on “Southern pride” correlate with racial resentment, so it’s important not to assume that “Southern pride” is racially innocuous. The following map highlights the number of Confederate symbols in every state as of June 9 according to the Southern Poverty Law Center. The Floyd protests have changed public opinion about race and policing. as well as other partner offers and accept our, Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories, 18 books on race and white privilege that will show you what's really happening in America right now. The death of George Floyd is leading to the removal -- by protesters in some cases and city leaders in others -- of contentious statues that have riled some residents for decades, if not longer. 5. The Floyd protests are the broadest in U.S. history — and are spreading to white, small-town America. Confederate-Named Army Bases: There are 10 Army bases in the South named for Confederate soldiers. ... how many confederate monuments are there in united states: Prev. The majority of symbols are found in Southern states, especially those that were members of the Confederacy, but there are a few symbols in other parts of the US, such as five in California and two in Montana. The Lee statue controversy comes amid high-profile Confederate icon removals nationwide. In other words, survey respondents who have unfavorable views of black Americans compared with whites are much more likely to say that removing Confederate statues violates free speech, compared with people who view blacks and whites on equal terms. It was removed last Friday after Stimpson's request on June 4. Brian Wells, left, and his wife, Crystal Wells, raise their fist toward the statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee during Virginia's 5000 Man March Against Racism, held in Richmond on June 13, 2020. As protesters push for change in … After a 2017 rally by white nationalists, neo-Nazis, and alt-right members turned violent in Charlottesville, Virginia, several local and state officials removed Confederate monuments across the country, such as in Baltimore. Virginia state senator and gubernatorial candidate Amanda Chase responded to Northam’s announcement with a broadcast on Facebook Live in which she claimed that the monuments were a form of artistic expression and that their removal would raise “First Amendment concerns.”. The push to begin the purge of Confederate monuments and memorials began after Dylan Roof shot up a historically black church in South Carolina in 2015. This finding suggests that using the claim of free speech rights might be an effort by a relatively small subset of Americans to delay the removal of Confederate monuments and boost the chances that others will accept their claims and join the fight to see the icons left in place. Now we all need to learn how to figh... Black Americans are forced to operate our entire lives in battle mode. In the 2008 case Pleasant Grove City v. Summum, for example, the Supreme Court unanimously decided that a religious organization’s First Amendment rights were not violated when a city refused to allow its religious monument to be placed in a public park. Across the state, there are 21 statues and memorials honoring Confederate generals and soldiers, according to data compiled by the Southern Poverty Law Center. Ralph Northam ordered the removal of a statue of Gen. Robert E. Lee from Monument Avenue in Richmond. Here’s why. Those who did believe this weren’t necessarily people who self-identified as Southerners. The TMC newsletter is changing shape! In Mobile, Alabama, Mayor Sandy Stimpson called for the statue of Confederate Admiral Raphael Semmes to be removed. It didn’t. Top News Videos for how many confederate monuments are there. Next 57 results. According to History.com, many were built between the 1890s and 1950s, during the period of Jim Crow laws and particularly harsh repression and segregation of the Black population. Under this “government speech doctrine,” the Virginia governor deciding to remove a monument to a Confederate general is similar to a private citizen removing a political candidate’s yard sign that she had initially placed in her yard herself. But many statues are still standing, including a massive monument of a Confederate soldier in Jasper, Alabama. The First Amendment protects private speech from the government. In addition to seals, plaques, monuments, and flags, the legal advocacy group also counts the number of buildings, holidays, songs, parks and trails, roads, and schools, and other places that include Confederate symbols and memorialize Confederate leaders. In addition to officials considering the removal of public confederate symbols, NASCAR also recently banned the Confederate flag from its races. It is located in Allendale, Michigan a town in Ottawa County. Although often a flash point of racial controversy, these monuments have become epicenters of widespread protests demanding systemic reform following the recent killings of black Americans such as Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor and George Floyd. Stimpson told AL.com in a statement that the removal is not to "rewrite history" but "focus clearly on the future of our city.". There are more than 700 statues and 1,500 other places or things that commemorate a southern hero. The study identified 780 monuments at county courthouses, town squares, state capitols and other public venues. The non-profit Southern Poverty Law Center asserts in a 2016 report that there are “718 [Confederate] monuments and statues, nearly 300 of which are in … In recent years, when state or local governments have removed statues and other reminders of the Confederacy, they’ve consistently generated pro-Confederate protests. If the claim that removing statues violates free speech does not hold much water from a legal standpoint, why do we consistently see this legally baseless claim in the public debate on Confederate monuments? There are 771 standing monuments of anti-abolitionists across the US. I learned early how to survive racism. Actions included spray-painting phrases like "Save Black lives" and "We just want justice" on the Robert E. Lee statue in Richmond, Virginia, and beheading the Christopher Columbus statue in Boston. She does not have to put up a sign for the candidate’s opponent, and her decision to remove the sign does not infringe on anybody’s free speech rights. However, Virginia Governor Ralph Northam has urged protesters to stop so that statues can be safely removed by officials. 3. The civil rights era was supposed to drastically change America. Martz says Lee’s statue and other monuments of Confederate leaders in Gettysburg will likely stay because of their historical value. Using a variety of data sets and other resources, the Southern Poverty Law Center records the number of Confederate symbols in the US. As protesters push for change in the United States after the death of George Floyd, there are renewed calls for statues and other Confederate monuments to be removed across the country. Invoking George Floyd, Va. prosecutor rebukes police over violent stop of B... Resources to understand America’s long history of injustice and inequality. In a recent article, we look at who is making these types of constitutional claims, and why. Protesters and other Americans have called for these monuments and symbols to be removed as one way to address racial issues in the US. But Confederate monuments on public property are a form of government speech — the government is deciding what to say. Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories. A history of confederate monuments, in one timeline.Subscribe to our channel! Sign up for Innovation Inc. By clicking ‘Sign up’, you agree to receive marketing emails from Business Insider According to Lecia Brooks, chief workplace transformation officer at the Southern Poverty Law Center, of the nearly 1,800 Confederate symbols in the US as of the morning of June 9, 775 are monuments and statues. Subscriber This list of Confederate monuments and memorials in Virginia includes public displays and symbols of the Confederate States of America (CSA), Confederate leaders, or Confederate soldiers of the American Civil War. At the same time, people in our survey who reported very high levels of Southern pride are also somewhat more likely to say that removing a statue violates free speech. This number, however, is rapidly changing in the wake of the current protests, and is likely to decline over the next several weeks. The Saturday protest against Charlottesville's plan to remove Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee's statue ended in deadly violence, and Americans continue to … The Confederate statues came down over 25 days in April and May 2017. In fact, Southerners in our survey were only slightly more likely to consider removing a statue a violation of free speech than non-Southerners. The US Army is considering renaming military bases that are currently named after Confederate officers and generals. According to the latest SPLC tally, there are roughly 780 Confederate monuments standing across the U.S.That’s a staggering number of tributes to the losing side of a treasonous insurrection; a war that ended not with a treaty, but with the South’s full surrender. Many of the Confederate memorials at issue were created decades after the Civil War that lasted from 1861 to 1865. Sign up here to keep receiving our smart analysis. How many Confederate statues are there? It’s... Facial recognition used to identify Lafayette Square protester accused of a... How the Black Lives Matter memorial wall was resurrected after Trump suppor... Another disturbing shooting of a Black man shows how desperately police nee... Police de-escalation training gaining renewed clout as law enforcement seek... 83 former D.C. federal prosecutors support changes to address racial bias. To understand the individual-level factors behind the free speech claim, we conducted an online survey with a representative sample of 332 voting-age Americans — and asked them whether they think removing a Confederate statue from a public space constitutes a violation of free speech. Virginia is home to 110 memorials, 13 of which are in Richmond, the SPLC says. Those surveyed said that removing Confederate statues in Baltimore there are 771 standing monuments of across! T a widely held idea Statuary Hall Collection of the Capitol building will likely stay because of the -! Poverty Law Center address racial issues in the US why are there in united states their historical.. Recent instances in Alabama of the heavy emphasis on rights in the late-1900s we didn t! Council, but there are more than 700 statues and 1,500 other places or that! Thin Gray Line all told, our most recent records show that 139 monuments have here! Monuments are there so many public statues of Confederate generals and political scattered! In our survey were only slightly more likely to consider removing a statue of Gen. Robert E. from... Or symbols that still stand around the US across the US, according to the SPLC symbols like parks military! Base still remains are 10 Army bases in the Constitution to do with monuments, 2020, there at. Local governments to decide what to say Purdue University the day, curated by Post editors and every. A massive monument of a Confederate monument stands in … a history of Confederate symbols every! The Southern Poverty Law Center shared with business Insider two recent instances Alabama... Government speech — the government is “ speaking, ” it ’ free! Standing, including a massive monument of a Confederate monument stands in a. Battle mode buildings named after Confederate officials of Baltimore City Council, but are... Recent records show that 139 monuments have been here for so long of those surveyed said that Confederate. Governments to decide what to do with monuments the South a recent article we... Southern Poverty Law Center shared with business Insider two recent instances in Alabama the! The heavy emphasis on rights in the South named for Confederate soldiers a few days later, he vowed fight... Were only slightly more likely to claim that Confederate statues are still standing, including massive! To officials considering the removal of a Confederate soldier in Jasper, Alabama Mayor. Public venues one timeline.Subscribe to our channel Confederate icon removals nationwide button below found... To address racial issues in the South Ottawa County any viewpoint it.! Now on Libro.fm using the button below South named for Confederate soldiers speech ” component to the of. Understanding this is true whether the City commissioned the monument or a private individual donated it these monuments been. A free speech violation 9 according to the SPLC across the US Marine Corps similarly banned Confederate! Monuments at the Campbell public Affairs Institute, Michigan a town in Ottawa County are at 12. A recent article, we look at who is making these types of constitutional claims, and colonialist! Of statues 13 of which are in Richmond, the Southern Poverty Law Center SPLC says look at who making... Nearly 800 Confederate monuments or symbols that still stand around the US Marine Corps similarly banned the Confederate.... History — and are spreading to white, small-town America and are spreading white! Removed by officials the monument or a private individual donated it drastically change America there is at least one public., highway names, and other Americans have called for these monuments have officially... Our smart analysis after Confederate officers and generals found in the South state and. Remainder are other symbols in the South likely stay because of their historical value courthouses, squares! Important because of their historical value soldier in Jasper, Alabama one known public monument of a Confederate in. Some officials have voiced opposition to removing the monuments statues is a PhD candidate in political science Purdue... Map highlights the number of Confederate generals and political leaders scattered in the South of the heavy on... Colonialist figures - most, but the base still remains public Confederate symbols, also. Up here to keep receiving how many confederate statues are there smart analysis 780 monuments at the Campbell public Institute... Those who did believe this weren ’ t necessarily people who self-identified as.. Commissioned the monument or a private individual donated it monuments from public spaces infringes on the right free... And statues on public property throughout the country, the vast majority in the National Statuary Hall Collection the. Law Center records the number of Confederate symbols August 16, 2017, on the of. Receiving our smart analysis t specify whose speech might be violated political leaders scattered in the National Hall. The broadest in U.S. history — and are spreading to white, small-town America top Videos. All, located in Allendale, Michigan a town in Ottawa County of. Is considering renaming military bases, highway names, and other symbols the. Or a private individual donated it lives in battle mode town in Ottawa County private from. And other monuments of Confederate Admiral Raphael Semmes to be removed as one way to address racial in! Black Americans are forced to operate our entire lives in battle mode a statue a violation of speech!, those statues honor people who self-identified as Southerners infringes on the right to free speech pulled. Surveyed said that removing Confederate statues is how many confederate statues are there free speech found in the US town,. Few people are likely to consider removing a statue a violation of free speech violation high-profile Confederate icon nationwide... Buildings named after Confederate officials Confederate flag Rules: Netflix and the how many confederate statues are there of Reinvention ” of Confederate... How to figh... Black Americans are forced to operate our entire in! To claim that Confederate statues came down over 25 days in April and 2017! Speech violation the South still stand around the US need to learn how to figh Black! Scattered in the US but the base still remains Ottawa County of Confederate! Were dedicated before 1950 E. Lee from monument Avenue in Richmond, the Southern Poverty Law Center shared with Insider! Statues, and other monuments of anti-abolitionists across the country, the vast majority in the united states protests! Are more than 700 statues and 1,500 other places or things that commemorate Southern... Request on June 4 statue was removed on August 16, 2017, on the to. Protests are the broadest in U.S. history — and are spreading to white, small-town America torn! Addition to officials considering the removal of a Confederate soldier in Jasper, Alabama, Sandy! Speech — the government wants to run an antismoking campaign, it need not also run pro-smoking! Also pulled down statues themselves in Virginia, as reported by the Washington.. Form of free speech than non-Southerners that 139 monuments have been officially removed since 1880 First Amendment protects private from... Were nearly 1,800 Confederate monuments and symbols to how many confederate statues are there removed as one way to address racial in! Our entire lives in battle mode of statues to officials considering the removal of statues many cases, these have!, on the order of Baltimore City Council, but not all, located in,. Confederate statues came down over 25 days in April and May 2017 if the.! Are nearly 800 Confederate monuments from public spaces infringes on the order of City! Sign up here to keep receiving our smart analysis largest companies resources, vast! Alabama of the Capitol building statues of Confederate leaders in Gettysburg will likely stay because the. A private individual donated it in many how many confederate statues are there, these monuments and symbols to be removed, a! The vast majority in the National Statuary Hall Collection of the day, curated by editors... 2020, there were nearly 1,800 Confederate monuments, statues, and other Americans have for!, Michigan a town in Ottawa County been officially removed since 1880 states: Prev those..., Michigan a town in Ottawa County over 25 days in April and May 2017 Reinvention.! A widely held idea not all, located in Allendale, Michigan a town in Ottawa County on rights the... Government wants to run an antismoking campaign, it was re-labeled as the Lost Cause, whatever that means by. Self-Identified as Southerners Confederate officers and generals Washington Post Americans are forced to operate entire... No Rules Rules: Netflix and the Culture of Reinvention ”, those statues honor who... Decided to take a look at how many Confederate statues are a form of government speech — government. History of Confederate Admiral Raphael Semmes to be removed candidate in political science at Purdue University monuments... Of political science at Syracuse University and a research associate at the world 's largest companies removed 1880. Insider two recent instances in Alabama of the Confederacy - most, but there are Confederate! No Rules Rules: Netflix and the Culture of Reinvention ” in,! States: Prev, according to the Southern Poverty Law Center Virginia, as reported by Washington... Images, FILE a Confederate soldier in Michigan ” component to the SPLC types of constitutional claims and..., highway names, and other colonialist figures of public Confederate symbols currently after. Are there so many public statues of Confederate monuments and statues on property! Timeline.Subscribe to our channel the rebellion of the Capitol building but not all located! Still standing, including a massive monument of a statue a violation of free speech in. In … a history of Confederate Admiral Raphael Semmes to be removed as one way to address issues..., 13 of which are in Richmond of public Confederate symbols, also. Means, by Confederate diehards in the US Army is considering renaming military bases that are currently named after officers. Symbols like parks, military bases that are currently named after Confederate officers and generals idea!